6/13/25
Mixed feelings
Upsides:
- Unique living spaces in historic building
- Great customer centered maintenance person
Downside:
- Worst apartment manager ever
Review from Apartments.com

155 S Poplar St, Elizabethtown, PA 17022
$1,200 - $1,445
Studio - 1 Bed
Monthly Rent
$1,200 - $1,445
Bedrooms
Studio - 1 Bed
Bathrooms
1 Bath
Only $500 security deposit
The fees below are based on community-supplied data independent market research.
Interview Required. $250 non-refundable deposit. $25 per month per pet (2 pet limit).
$250 non-refundable deposit. $25 per month per pet (2 pet limit).
Property Fee Disclaimer: Based on community-supplied data and independent market research. Subject to change without notice. May exclude fees for mandatory or optional services and usage-based utilities.

Walk Score ®
Very Walkable80 / 100
Bike Score ®
Bikeable62 / 100
4 Ratings & Reviews
6/13/25
Upsides:
- Unique living spaces in historic building
- Great customer centered maintenance person
Downside:
- Worst apartment manager ever
Review from Apartments.com
5/28/22
I'm new to Elizabethtown and grateful to have found Peach Alley Court. The apartments are spacious and beautiful. Dawn has been a joy to rent from and very helpful with every little thing I needed along the way. Maintenance requests are done in a timely manner. The location in town is great, too. From the beautiful apartments, kind staff, and great location - you can't beat it!
Review from Apartments.com
4 People Found This Helpful
1/15/20
Dawn the building manager is the best one I ever had. Hands down she will rush to your needs 24/7. I had a 6-month lease which was priced fairly. The only con I can think of is the Maintenence staff takes awhile to respond to a work order request. The gym is nothing special and very small FYI.
Review from Apartments.com
6 People Found This Helpful
10/21/16
I used to live in these apartments and had an absolutely horrible experience. The building is outdated, and heat costs a fortune in the winter due to the window drafts/ ac costs a fortune in the summer. Smoking is supposed to be away from entry ways, but this rule is not enforced and all butt containers are near entryways. The dumpster area is an eye sore as there frequently old furniture, Christmas trees, and overflowing garbage in the area. Not only was this a health issue (as one time there... was used tampons on the ground) but also a perfect place for rodents. There was frequent maintenance concerns, which typically were addressed sub-par or not the same business day. Once a resident even passed on the ground level and wasnt discovered until the smell peaked interest. The high ceilings, old rustic look, and location make this property appealing, but the negative aspects outweigh the positive substantially. I moved out about 2 years ago, and thankfully so. I would never rent here again.
-Heather
Review from Apartments.com
36 People Found This Helpful
Property Manager at Peach Alley Court responded to this review
Heather, we cannot verify that you were ever a resident, but we are sorry if you had a bad experience. We try very hard to satisfy our residents and always welcome feedback.
Shoppers will appreciate Peach Alley Court proximity to Elizabethtown Shopping Center and Market Street Square. Elizabethtown Shopping Center is 1.3 miles away, and Market Street Square is within a 29 minute walk.
Recreational activities near Peach Alley Court are plentiful. Discover 1 park within 2.9 miles, including Conewago Recreation Trail.
Living in Elizabethtown provides easy access to Harrisburg International, located just 19 minutes from Peach Alley Court.
Open By Appointment Only